Samanvayasutra

SamanSuttam

41. Samanvayasutra

PRECEPTS ON RECONCILIATION хЕ│ф║Ощб║ф╗О

Savvam pi aneyamtam, parokkharuvena jam payasedi.

Tam suyananam bhannadi, samsaya-pahudihi paricattam. (722)

That (knowledge) which reveals the multiple aspects of the things in an indirect form and is free from any doubt etc. is designated as scriptural knowledge. (722)

шГ╜хдЯф╗ещЧ┤цОечЪДх╜вх╝ПцЭецПнчд║ф║ЛцГЕчЪДхдЪф╕кцЦ╣щЭвх╣╢ф╕Фф╕Нф╝ЪщАацИРчЦСцГСчЪДчЯешпЖцИРф╕║хЕ╕ч▒НчЯешпЖуАВ

Loyanam vavaharam,dhamma-vivakkhai jo pasahedi.

Suyananassa viyappo, so vi nao limgasambhudo. (723)

That (knowledge) which makes possible the transactions of the people and illuminates the desired property of the thing, is a naya which is subtype of srutajnana and born of a probans. (723)

чЯешпЖшГ╜хдЯф╜┐ф║║ф╗мф║дцШУцИРхКЯя╝Мх╣╢ф╜┐ф║║ф╗мчЬЛхИ░цГ│шжБф║ЖшзгчЪДф║ЛчЙйчЪДчЙ╣цАзя╝Мш┐Щх░▒цШпNayaя╝МsrutajnanaчЪДф╕АчзНя╝МчФ▒probansц╝ФхПШшАМцЭеуАВ

┬а

Nanadhammajudam pi ya, eyam dhammam pi vuccade attham.

Tasseyavivakkhado, natthi vivakkha hu sesanam. (724)

Although a thing is possessed of so many properties, yet it is referred to by only one of these properties, because at that time exposition of only that property is required and not the remaining others.

(724)

х░╜чобф╕Аф╕кф║ЛчЙйхЕ╖цЬЙхдЪчзНчЙ╣цАзя╝Мф╜ЖцШпхПкщЬАшжБц╢ЙхПКхоГчЪДф╕Аф╕кх▒ЮцАзя╝МхЫаф╕║хПкщЬАшжБф║ЖшзгхоГчЪДф╕Аф╕кчЙ╣цАзя╝МшАМф╕НщЬАшжБф║ЖшзгхЕ╢ф╗ЦчЪДуАВ

Te savekkha sunaya, niravekkha te vi dunnaya homti.

Sayala-vavahara-siddhi, sunayado hodi nayamena. (725)

The view, which accepts the relativity or mutual dependence of these properties, is a case of naya proper (Sunaya) while the view that does not, is a case of naya-improper (Durnaya). It is the rule that all the transactions become successful when based on a naya proper. (725)

цЙ┐шодф║ЛчЙйчЙ╣цАзчЪДчЫ╕хп╣цАзф╗ехПКчЫ╕ф║Тф╛ЭхнШцАзчЪДшзВчВ╣хПлхБЪSunayaя╝Ыф╕ОхЕ╢чЫ╕хп╣чЪДх░▒цШпDurnaya

).хжВцЮЬцМЙчЕзSunayaчЪДхКЮц│ХцЭехдДчРЖф║ЛцГЕчЪДшпЭя╝МцЙАцЬЙчЪДф║ЛхКбщГ╜цИРцИРхКЯчЪДшзгхЖ│уАВ

Javamto vayanapadha, tavamto va naya “viтАШ saddao.

Te ceva ya parasamaya, sammattam samudiya savve. (726)

There are as many points of view as their are modes of expression, In case the word тАФalso” is employed every statement or expression represents Jaina position. The same provides an aliedn position, in case the word is not employed. Certainly right understanding demands a synthetic approach to all the statements about the thing. (726)

чФ▒ф║Оф║ЛчЙйцЬЙф╕НхРМчЪДчК╢цАБя╝МхЫацндш┐ШхнШхЬишо╕хдЪшзВчВ╣уАВцЬЙф╕АчВ╣хПпф╗ешВпхоЪхЬ░цШпя╝Мхп╣ф║ЛчЙйцнгчбочЪДчРЖшзгщЬАшжБхп╣ф║ЛчЙйцЬЙхЕищЭвчЪДшодшпЖуАВ

Parasamaeganayamayam, tappadivakkhanayao nivattejja.

Samae va pariggahiyam, parena jam dosabuddhie. (727)

Any specific extremistic view point adopted by rival, should be refuted by pointing out its rival viewpoint. The same should be our process, in case same person, following our own religious traditions adopts out of same faulty understanding any extremistic view. (727)

ф╗╗ф╜Ххп╣цЙЛцЙАщЗЗхПЦчЪДцЮБчлпчЪДшзВчВ╣я╝МщГ╜х║Фх╜УшвлцЙ╣хИдуАВцИСф╗мф╣ЯцШпф╕Аца╖я╝МхЬицЯРф║ЫцГЕхЖ╡ф╕Ля╝Мф║║ф╗мхПпшГ╜ф╝ЪхЫаф╕║ф╗Цф╗мчЪДхоЧцХЩф╣ацГпшАМф╗ОцЮБчлпчЪД
шзТх║жшАМх╛ЧхИ░щФЩшппчЪДшзВчВ╣уАВ

Niyayavayanijjasacca, savvanaya paraviyalane moha.

Te una na ditthasamao, vibhayai sacce va alie va. (728)

All view-point (nayas) are true in respect of what they have themselves to say but they are false so far as they refute a rival view-point (naya). One who is well-versed in the scriptures, should not divide the view-points (nayas) into true and false ones. (728)

ф╗╗ф╜ХшзТх║жщГ╜цШпцнгчбочЪДя╝Мх░▒хГПф╗Цф╗мшЗкх╖▒цЙАхогчз░чЪДф╕Аца╖уАВф╜ЖцШпф╕Аф╕кч▓╛щАЪф║ОхЕ╕ч▒НчЪДф║║х║Фх╜УцККф╗ЦчЬЛщЧощвШчЪДшзТх║жхИЖф╕║цнгчбочЪДхТМщФЩшппчЪДуАВ

Na samenti na ya sameya, sammattam nava vatthuno gamaga.

Vatthuvighayaya naya, virohao verino ceva. (729)

Every absolute point of view is independent of the other, they cannot be united together and their union is not conducive to the right approach. They are independent of each other like the opposing enemies. (729)

ф╗╗ф╜Хч╗Эхп╣чЪДшзВчВ╣щГ╜цШпчЛмчлЛчЪДя╝МхоГф╕НшГ╜хдЯхРМхЕ╢ф╗ЦчЪДшзВчВ╣чЫ╕шБФч│╗я╝МхЫацндцЧахКйф║Оф║║ф╗мшО╖х╛ЧцнгчбочЪДшодшпЖуАВф╗Цф╗мх░▒хГПхп╣члЛчЪДцХМф║║ф╕Аца╖чЫ╕ф║ТчЛмчлЛуАВ

Savve samayanti sammam, cegavasao naya viruddha vi.

Bhicca-vavaharino iva, raodasina-vasavatti. (730)

Even though a single view-point (naya) taken, be itself may appear to be opposed to the other (naya), yet when they are considered mutually dependent to others, they would be conducive to the right understanding. Like the servants who act in harmony when they come under common control, even though they may be differing when they are separated. (730)

хН│ф╜┐цШпхПкцЬЙф╕Аф╕кшзВчВ╣я╝Мф╣ЯхПпшГ╜ф╝ЪхЗ║чО░чЯЫчЫ╛я╝Мф╜ЖцШпх╜УхоГхРМхЕ╢ф╗ЦшзВчВ╣чЫ╕шБФч│╗цЧ╢я╝МхоГх░▒хПпшГ╜цЬЙхКйф║ОшО╖х╛ЧцнгчбочЪДшодшпЖуАВх░▒хГПф╗Жф║║ф╕Аца╖я╝Мх░╜чобхРДф╕НчЫ╕хРМя╝МхН┤шГ╜хдЯхТМш░РчЪДхЬиф╕Аш╡╖х╖еф╜ЬуАВ

Jamanegadhammano vatthuno, aadamse ca savvapadivatti.

Amdha vva gayavayave to, micchadditthino visu. (731)

Those, who treat some one portion or aspect of a thing as a whole thing, have a wrong understanding like those blind persons who treated some one particular part of an elephant as a whole elephant.

(731)

щВгф║ЫцККф║ЛцГЕчЪДщГихИЖцИЦшАЕф╕Аф╕кцЦ╣щЭвх╜Уф╜ЬцХ┤ф╕кф║ЛцГЕцЭешодшпЖчЪДф║║х░Жф╝Ъх╛ЧхИ░ф╕Аф╕кщФЩшппчЪДшодшпЖя╝Мш┐Щх░▒хГПчЫ▓ф║║цС╕ш▒бф╕Аца╖уАВ

Jam puna samattapajjaya-vatthugamaga tti samudiya tenam.

Sammattam cakkhumao, savvagayavayavagahane vva. (732)

Those, who take together all the stand-points and thus grasp all the aspects of a thing, have a right understanding just as those with eyes, are able be grasp an elephant as a whole. (732)

щВгф║ЫшГ╜хдЯф╗ОцЙАцЬЙчЪДшзТх║жцЭечЬЛщЧощвШчЪДф║║я╝МшГ╜хдЯх╛ЧхИ░цнгчбочЪДшодшпЖя╝Ых░▒хГПф╕Аф╕кхБех║╖чЪДф║║шГ╜хдЯчЬЛц╕ЕцХ┤ф╕кхдзш▒бф╕Аца╖уАВ

Pannavanijja bhava, anamtabhago tu anabhilappanam.

Pannavanijjanam puna, anamtabhago sudanibaddho. (733)

The properties of the things, capable of being described are infinite times less than those not capable of being described, while the properties described in the scriptures are infinite times less than those who are describable (In view of such problems, how can it be said that the statement of such a scripture of person is absolutely true). (733)

чЙйф╜УчЪДчЙ╣цАзя╝Мф╕НшГ╜хдЯцППш┐░хЗ║цЭечЪДшжБш┐Ьш┐ЬхдЪф║ОшГ╜хдЯцППш┐░хЗ║цЭечЪДя╝МшАМхЬихЕ╕ч▒Нф╕нцЙАцППш┐░чЪДхПИш┐Ьш┐Ьх░Сф║ОшГ╜хдЯцППш┐░хЗ║цЭечЪДя╝Иш┐Щца╖чЪДшпЭя╝МхПИцАОф╣ИшГ╜шп┤хЕ╕ч▒Нф╕нчЪДхПЩш┐░щГ╜цШпхоМхЕицнгчбочЪДчЪДхСвя╝Яя╝ЙуАВ

Sayam sayam pasamsamta, garhamta param vayam.

┬аJe u tattha viussamti, samsaram te viussiya. (734)

Those, who go on praising their own view and condemning those of their rival, simply make a show of their learning and are variously in the grip of transmigratory cycle. (734)

щВгф║ЫчЯешпЖщ╝УхР╣шЗкх╖▒чЪДшзВчВ╣шАМшпЛцпБхп╣цЙЛшзВчВ╣чЪДф║║чЪДчЯешпЖхТМшзБшпЖщГ╜хНБхИЖчЛнчкДуАВ

Nanajiva nanakammam, nanaviham have laddhi.

Tamha vayanavivadam, sagaparasamaehim vajjijja. (735)

There are various types of people, various types of their activities, various types of (their) capabilities. Hence one ought to give up quarrelling either with the people of oneтАШs own faith and also with that of the others. (735)

ф╕ЦчХМф╕КцЬЙхРДх╝ПхРДца╖чЪДф║║я╝МхРДх╝ПхРДца╖чЪДшбМф╕║я╝МхРДх╝ПхРДца╖чЪДшГ╜хКЫуАВхЫацндф║║ф╗мх║Фх╜УцФ╛х╝ГхРМхИлф║║хЕ│ф║Оф┐бф╗░щЧощвШчЪДф║ЙхР╡уАВ

Bhaddam micchadamsana-samuhamaiyassa amayasarassa.

Jinavayanassa bhagavao, samviggasuhahigammassa. (736)

Let glory be to the holy teaching of Jinas which is of the form of conglommeration of all false views; which is possessed of a nectar and is easy of comprehenstion by those who are desirous to attain emancipation. (736)

цККшНгшкЙш╡Рч╗ЩJinaчЪДхнжшп┤хРзя╝Мф╗ЦцСТх╝Гф║ЖцЙАцЬЙщФЩшппчЪДшзВчВ╣я╝Мхо╣цШУф╕║хПпцЬЫшО╖х╛ЧшзгшД▒чЪДф║║ф╗мцЙАчРЖшзгуАВ